| OFFSEASON OUTLOOK | 2009 40 MAN ROSTER | Rule V Eligible | ||||||
| Mike Finocchi | ||||||||
| Targets | CURRENT COUNT | 40 | Neil Wagner | |||||
| POSITION | SECOND BASEMEN | YEARS | ASK/SIGN PRICE | COMPETITORS/TEAM | CATCHER | Joanniel Montero | ||
| 2B | Mark Ellis, Oakland | 2 Years | $11 Million | Oakland Athletics | Victor Martinez | Hector Rondon | 40 | |
| 2B, 3B, SS, OF | Jerry Hairston Jr., Cincinnati | Kelly Shoppach | Randy Newsome | |||||
| 2B | Dan Uggla, Florida | Carlos Santana | Carlos Santana | 40 | ||||
| THIRD BASEMEN | Wyatt Toregas | Chuck Lofgren | ||||||
| 3B | Garrett Atkins, Colorado | Chris Gimenez | Jason Denham | |||||
| 1B, 3B, OF | Casey Blake, Los Angeles D | 3 Years | $17 Million | Los Angeles Dodgers | FIRST BASE | Chris Gimenez | 40 | |
| 1B, 3B | Hank Blalock, Texas + | Ryan Garko | Carlton Smith | |||||
| 1B, 2B, 3B | Jorge Cantu, Florida | SECOND BASE | Shawn Nottingham | |||||
| 3B | Craig Counsell, Milwaukee | Asdrubal Cabrera | Cirilo Cumberbatch | |||||
| 3B | Joe Crede, Chicago W + | Jamey Carroll | Juan Valdes | |||||
| 3B | Edwin Encarnacion, Cincinnati | Josh Barfield | Scott Roehl | |||||
| 3B | Mike Lowell, Boston | Luis Valbuena | Brandon Pinckney | |||||
| 2B, 3B | Mark Loretta, Houston | 1 Year | $1.25 Million | Los Angeles Dodgers | THIRD BASE | Ryan Goleski | ||
| 3B | Doug Mientkiewicz, Pittsburgh | Andy Marte | Jeff Stevens | *CHC | ||||
| 3B | Melvin Mora, Baltimore | Mark DeRosa | Stephen Head | |||||
| 3B | Mark Teahen, Royals | SHORT STOP | Frank Herrmann | |||||
| 1B, 3B | Ty Wiggington, Astros | Jhonny Peralta | Trevor Crowe | 40 | ||||
| OUTFIELDERS | LEFT FIELD | Jordan Brown | ||||||
| OF | Raul Ibanez, Seattle | 3 Years | $31.5 Million | Philadelphia Phillies | Ben Francisco | Kevin Dixon | ||
| STARTING PITCHERS | David Dellucci | Ryan Edell | ||||||
| SP | Paul Byrd, Boston | CENTER FIELD | Jose Constanza | |||||
| SP | Ryan Dempster, Chicago C | 4 Years | $52 Million | Chicago Cubs | Grady Sizemore | Lucas Montero | ||
| SP | Freddy Garcia, Detroit | Trevor Crowe | Angel Rodriguez | |||||
| SP | Livan Hernandez, Colorado | RIGHT FIELD | Alex Castillo | |||||
| SP | Randy Johnson, Arizona + | 1 Year | $8 Million | San Francisco Giants | Shin-Soo Choo | Richard Martinez | ||
| SP | Kyle Lohse, St. Louis | 4 Years | $41 Million | St. Lous Cardinals | DESIGNATED HITTER | Carlos Arias | V | |
| SP | Braden Looper, St. Louis | Travis Hafner | Jose Jimenez | |||||
| SP | Derek Lowe, Los Angeles D | STARTING PITCHER | Anillins Martinez | |||||
| SP | Mark Mulder, St. Louis + | Cliff Lee | Sandy Mendez | |||||
| SP | Carl Pavano, New York Y + | 1 Year | $1.5 Million | CLEVELAND INDIANS | Fausto Carmona | Joe Ness | ||
| SP | Brad Penny, Los Angeles D + | 1 Year | Boston Red Sox | Jake Westbrook | Jorge Riera | |||
| SP | C.C. Sabathia, Milwaukee | 7 Years | HAHAHA $161 Mil | New York Yankees | Anthony Reyes | Juan Aponte | ||
| SP | Ben Sheets, Milwaukee + | Aaron Laffey | Cristo Arnal | |||||
| SP | Randy Wolf, Houston | Jeremy Sowers | Jerad Head | |||||
| RELIEVERS | Zach Jackson | Jansy Infante | ||||||
| RP | Luis Ayala, New York M | Carl Pavano | Isaias Velasquez | |||||
| RP | Chad Cordero, Washington | Scott Lewis | Rafael Quintero | V | ||||
| RP | Juan Cruz, Arizona | Hector Rondon | Minor League FAs | |||||
| RP | Bob Howry, Chicago C | 1 Year | $2.75 Million | San Francisco Giants | RELIEF PITCHER | TJ Burton | ||
| RP | Damaso Marte, New York Y | 3 Years | $12 Million | New York Yankees | Rafael Perez | Bubbie Buzachero | ||
| RP | Will Ohman, Atlanta | Rafael Betancourt | Matt Ginter | # | ||||
| RP | Dennys Reyes, Minnesota | Masahide Kobayashi | John Halama | |||||
| CLOSERS | John Meloan | Jeff Harris | ||||||
| CL | Brian Fuentes, Colorado | 2 Years | $17 Million | Los Angeles Angels | Edwin Mujica | Juan Lara | ||
| CL | Kevin Gregg, Florida | TRADED | FROM FLORIDA | TO CHICAGO (CUBS) | Jensen Lewis | Preston Larrison | *WAS | |
| CL | Trevor Hoffman, San Diego | Rich Rundles | JD Martin | *WAS | ||||
| CL | Jason Isringhausen, St. Louis | Adam Miller | Jeff Weaver | |||||
| CL | Brandon Lyon, Arizona | Tony Sipp | Armando Camacaro | $ | ||||
| CL | J.J. Putz, Seattle | TRADED | FROM SEATTLE | TO NEW YORK (METS) | Kerry Wood | Yamid Haad | ||
| CL | Francisco Rodriguez, LAA | 3 Years | $37 Million | New York Mets | Joe Smith | Damaso Espino | $ | |
| CL | BJ Ryan, Toronto | Matt Whitney | *WAS | |||||
| CL | Huston Street, Colorado | Andy Cannizaro | $ | |||||
| SP, CL | John Smoltz, Atlanta | COLOR KEY | STATUS | Brandon Chaves | ||||
| CL | Kerry Wood, Chicago + | 2 Years | $20 Million | CLEVELAND INDIANS | Green | 25 Man Roster | Niuman Romero | |
| CL | Jose Valverde, Houston | Blue | Rule V Addition | Morgan Ensberg | ||||
| INDIANS FREE AGENTS | Red | In Danger | Tony Graffanino | |||||
| Catcher | Sal Fasano | 1 Year | Minor League Deal | Colorado Rockies | Gold | New Addition | Jason Cooper | |
| Infielder | Jamey Carroll | Option Year | $2.5 Million | PICKED UP | Orange | Fighting For 25 Man | Andy Gonzalez | |
| Pitcher | Matt Ginter | Purple | Injured, Not On 40 Man | Todd Linden | ||||
| Reliever | Brendan Donnelly | 1 Year | Minor League Deal | Texas Rangers | Black | Minor Leagues | Nathan Panther | |
| Reliever | Juan Rincon | 1 Year | Minor League Deal | Detroit Tigers | Bronson Sardinha | |||
| Reliever | Scott Elarton | Brian Slocum | *PIT | |||||
| ARBITRATION | ||||||||
| Catcher | Kelly Shoppach | 1 Year | $1.95 Million | Avoided, Re-Signed | ||||
| POSITION KEY | COLOR KEY | INDIANS ACQUISTIONS | INDIANS ACQUISITIONS | SYMBOL KEY | STATUS | |||
| FILLED | OUT OF PRICE RANGE | Position | Player | Contract | Pos, Player | Contract | Granted Free Agency | # |
| LUXURY | INJURY RISK = + | Pitcher | Chen-Chang Lee | Minor League Deal; $400K Bonus | P, Jack Cassel | Minor League Deal | Added to 40 Man | 40 |
| FLEXIBLE | LUXURY | Pitcher | Jose Rodriguez | Minor League Deal | P, Matt Herges | Minor League Deal | Taken in Rule 5 | V |
| BEST CASE SCENARIO | Pitcher | Greg Aquino | Minor League Deal | P, Vinnie Chulk | Minor League Deal | Re-signed | $ | |
| SHORT TERM SOLUTION | Pitcher | Tomo Ohka | Minor League Deal | IF, Jesus Merchan | Minor League Deal | New Team | * | |
| OUTSIDE POSSIBILITY | Pitcher | Kerry Wood | 2 Years, 20 Million, + Option Year | IF, Wilson Valdez | Minor League Deal | Outrighted By Indians | O | |
| FALL BACK OPTION | Pitcher | Joe Smith | Trade From NYM | OF, Mickey Hall | Traded From BOS(Byrd) | MLFA's Rule V Eligible if Resigned | ||
| IN PRICE RANGE | Infielder | Luis Valbuena | Trade From SEA | SP, Kirk Saarloos | Minor League Deal | |||
| OFFICIAL TARGET | Infielder | Mark DeRosa | Trade From CHC | |||||
| NEED FILLED | Pitcher | Carl Pavano | 1 Year, 1.5 Million + Incentives | |||||
| OFF THE MARKET | ||||||||
| RE-SIGN | INDIANS OUTGOING | INDIANS OUTGOING | ||||||
| LET GO | Pitcher | Tom Mastny | Sold to Japan | Pitcher | Jeff Stevens | Traded to Chicago | ||
| SIGNED BY TRIBE | Outfielder | Franklin Gutierrez | Traded to Seattle | Pitcher | John Gaub | Traded to Chicago | ||
| SIGNED BY OTHER TEAM | Pitcher | Chris Archer | Traded to Chicago | Outfielder | Ryan Goleski | Released | ||